أسئلة وأجوبة
Does this decision, dismissing the appeal and upholding the judgment, confirm that I won the case?
Hello,
I was involved in an appeal process and just received this notification from the court. What does it mean?
As the appellee, does this confirm that I won the case?
The judgment was scheduled to be delivered in today's hearing, and the court decided in chambers as follows:
- Accepting the appeal in form.
- Dismissing the appeal on the merits and upholding the appealed judgment.
- Ordering the appellant to bear the costs of the appeal.
The court notification you received means:
- Accepting the appeal in form: The court accepted the appeal procedurally, meaning the appeal was filed correctly and within the deadline.
- Dismissing the appeal on the merits and upholding the appealed judgment: The court rejected the appellant’s (other party’s) claims on substance and upheld the original judgment in your favor.
As the appellee, this confirms you have won the appeal. The original judgment stands.
Wait for the written judgment copy. Monitor for any cassation appeal (if applicable), as the opposing party may still have a right to appeal further depending on the case type.
We can review the judgment and guide you on any further steps if needed.
Contact us at [-------------].
Dismissing the appeal on the merits: This is the key part. "On the merits" means the court considered the actual substance of the appeal, and the arguments presented by the appellant.
By dismissing the appeal on the merits, the court is saying they rejected the appellant's arguments and found them unconvincing.
This confirms that the original decision (the one you won initially) stands. The appeal court is saying the lower court got it right.
Hello,
The court’s decision means that the appeal has been rejected, and the original judgment remains in force.
The phrase "Accepting the appeal in form" simply indicates that the appeal met the procedural requirements and was formally admitted for review.
However, the crucial part of the ruling is "Dismissing the appeal on the merits and upholding the appealed judgment," which confirms that the appeal was unsuccessful.
This means that the original judgment issued by the first-instance court remains unchanged and is still binding.
Dear Questioner,
Thank you for your inquiry!
Based on the court's ruling you received, here’s what the decision means:
- "Accepting the appeal in form":
This means that the court has accepted the appeal as valid and procedurally correct. This is a standard step in the appeal process, confirming that the appeal was filed in the proper manner.
- "Dismissing the appeal on the merits":
This part indicates that the court has reviewed the substance or the main arguments of the appeal and has rejected them. In other words, the appellant’s case was not successful, and the court did not find any valid reason to overturn the original decision.
- "Upholding the appealed judgment":
This means that the court has confirmed the original judgment that was made in your favor (if you are the appellee). Therefore, the decision made earlier remains valid and is not changed or reversed by the appeal court.
- "Ordering the appellant to bear the costs of the appeal":
This indicates that the appellant (the party who filed the appeal) will be responsible for paying the legal costs associated with the appeal, including court fees and possibly the legal fees of the other party.
Conclusion:
Yes, based on the court’s decision, it confirms that you won the case in the appeal process. The original judgment remains in effect, and the appellant will need to bear the costs of the appeal.
If you need further clarification or would like to discuss your next steps, please feel free to reach out.
Best regards,
Mohammed Salah
Legal Consultant
