Questions & Answers

Ask a lawyer
Dubai, UAE

How to appeal a civil case judgment if it was based on a forged document?

Hi all professionals,

I lost a civil case against a fraud immigration consultant based in Dubai on 14 March 2024. I was the plaintiff and I had paid AED 24600 to him for migrating to Canada.

He submitted a forged document on 7 Dec 2023 with his memo. I replied to that and submitted the original document which I received from the government of Canada the same document which this company had forged.

Despite that, the court gave the judgment based on the fake document submitted by the defendant, and it is the final judgment.

How can I appeal as I have been told that I can't file an appeal against this final judgment?

How can a judge pass judgment on a fake document?

Please advise.

Premium
London Center for Legal Consultancy Office
Chat Hire
Meet
18 Mar 2024, 06:55

We are pleased to respond to your consultation.

I understand your frustration after losing your civil case against the fraudulent immigration adviser. I'll try to help you understand your options in terms of appeal.

Can you appeal?

The possibility of appeal depends on several factors, including:

Type of court that rendered judgment: Judgements of first instance may be appealed to the Court of Appeal.

Value of the claim: There must be a minimum amount of the claim to be subject to appeal.

Reason for appeal: You must have a strong legal reason to appeal, such as an error of law or procedure.

In your case:

Court type: I don't know what kind of court delivered the judgment, so I can't be sure that it can be appealed.

Litigation Value: You stated that you paid AED 24,600, which is above the minimum value for appealing a civil case in Dubai.

Reason for appeal: You have a strong legal reason to appeal, which is that the judgment was rendered on the basis of a forged document.

For further inquiries about your topic, you can reach our office or contact us on WhatsApp.

18 Mar 2024, 06:59

This is the judgment.

18 Mar 2024, 07:01

Thank you.

Premium
Al Fahad Legal Consulting
Chat Hire
Meet
18 Mar 2024, 09:01

Dear M.,

Thanks for your inquiry.

Regarding the above, we would like to inform you that, according to UAE law, a final judgment cannot be appealed.

However, you may be able to file a cassation appeal to the Court of Cassation, which is the highest court in the UAE.

This type of appeal can only be filed on specific grounds, such as a violation of the law or a procedural error.

You will need to consult with us to determine if you have grounds for a cassation appeal in your case.

Additionally, you may also consider filing a complaint with the relevant authorities, such as the Dubai Police or the Dubai Public Prosecution, for the fraud committed by the immigration consultant.

They may be able to investigate and take legal action against the consultant.

It is important to note that the legal process in the UAE can be complex and it is recommended to seek advice from us. We will be able to guide you on the best course of action to take in your specific case.

Kindly feel free to contact us by email.

Greetings,

Premium
Middle East Legal Consultants
Chat Hire
Meet
18 Mar 2024, 09:08

You can register for re-opening the case to review it again and prove the fake document or request to send the fake document to the criminal laboratory to confirm it's a fake document.

Premium
Amiri Advocates & Legal Consultants
Chat Hire
Meet
18 Mar 2024, 18:25

It is not enough to tell the court that the document is forged; you must request the court to send the document to the forensic laboratory for examination.

The judge does not direct the opponents and does not ask them to say what they are supposed to say.

Get quotes from lawyers
Find the right lawyer for your legal needs. Submit your request and get multiple competitive offers from qualified lawyers.
Looking for something else?
Ask for advice from a lawyer
It’s free and anonymous
No registration needed
Ask a lawyer