أسئلة وأجوبة
Unpaid agency commission without a signed agreement. Can email proof hold up in court?
Hi dear all,
This question concerns the payment of the agency commission. The commission agreement form was not signed, but there is indirect evidence — email correspondence in which it is confirmed that the 2% amount is intended for the agent’s commission.
In the end, the client refuses to pay, although the deal was completed.
How realistic is it to receive the commission through a court decision? And how long would such a case typically take?
Dear Inquirer,
Even without a signed commission agreement, email correspondence confirming the 2% commission can serve as valid evidence in court. The key factors in determining the case’s strength include:
- Proof of Agreement:
If emails clearly establish the agent’s entitlement to commission, the claim is legally enforceable.
- Performance of Services:
Since the deal was completed, this strengthens your case.
- Legal Process & Timeline:
Commission disputes typically take a few months in UAE courts, depending on case complexity and evidence.
To assess the viability of legal action and ensure proper filing, we recommend booking a consultation with us. Our team can guide you on the best course of action, including potential court proceedings.
Contact us today!
This depends on the agreement between you and the customer. If the customer agreed in the correspondence to pay the commission percentage upon completing the transaction, a lawsuit can be filed to claim the commission.
Such cases usually take between 4 to 5 months. Contact us at the phone number [---------] so we can assist you.
In the UAE, and particularly in Dubai, electronic communications like emails can be considered valid evidence in court.
If the email correspondence clearly and unequivocally confirms the 2% commission agreement, it can serve as proof of a contractual obligation.
The court will look at the clarity and intent of the emails. If they clearly establish the terms of the commission, they can be accepted.
A civil case like this could potentially take 2-4 months. If you need further clarification or assistance, kindly share your WhatsApp number.
Dear questioner,
If the written communications show that the parties agreed on the commission, there is a possibility of claiming it, especially if you are a registered agent.
If you need further clarification, kindly share your WhatsApp number.
Dear Questioner,
Thank you for your inquiry!
Based on the details you provided, here’s a summary of your situation:
- Commission Without Signed Agreement:
Even without a signed commission agreement, the email evidence confirming the 2% commission may still be valid in court. The court will consider this as evidence of the agreement and can enforce payment if it shows mutual understanding and a completed transaction.
- Likelihood of Success:
Given the evidence and the fact that the deal was completed, it is realistic to expect a favorable court decision for the commission.
- Timeframe:
Typically, a civil case for commission enforcement could take 3 to 6 months, depending on the complexity of the case.
- Next Steps:
You can file a civil case with the court, providing the email evidence. If necessary, we can also consider negotiation or mediation before pursuing litigation.
Let me know if you need further assistance or would like to proceed.
Best regards,
Mohammed Salah
Legal Consultant
It is realistic to receive the commission through a court decision based on indirect evidence like email correspondence; however, success depends on various legal factors.
The duration for such cases typically ranges from several months to over a year.
Hello,
In this case, since there was no formal commission agreement signed, but there is email correspondence confirming the 2% commission to the agent, you have indirect evidence that can be used in court to support your claim.
- The Reality of Obtaining Commission Through a Court Decision:
In the UAE, if you have strong evidence of an agreement between you and the client (even if it is informal, such as an email), you can claim the commission through a lawsuit.
If the transaction was successful and the client utilized your services, the judge will likely rule in your favor based on the evidence provided, despite the absence of a written agreement.
- Claims Procedure:
You must gather all available evidence, including emails and correspondence that demonstrate the commission agreement, as well as proof of the completion of the transaction that merits the commission.
If the client does not pay the commission, you can file a civil lawsuit to claim the amount owed, and the judge will consider the case based on the available evidence and testimony.
- Case Duration:
Civil cases in the UAE typically take 3 to 6 months, but the time may vary depending on the circumstances of the case, such as the complexity of the evidence or delays in scheduling hearings. If the ruling is in your favor, a court judgment will be issued requiring the client to pay you the commission due.
For assistance, please contact us via phone or WhatsApp at [----------].
